Rules and FAQ

Who can take part?

Anyone. Share the link with anyone who might want to join in.

How many reviews can I post?

As many different pies as you like. You get one review per pie, or two if you try it both hot and cold.

How many reviews does a pie need to count?

Three. Pies with fewer than three reviews don’t make the final table and can’t win.

How is the winner worked out?

Each pie’s score is the average of all its reviews. There are three tables: overall (hot and cold together), best cold and best hot. Each table only includes pies with at least three reviews in it.

What counts as a mince pie?

The filling must be mostly traditional mincemeat: dried fruit, spices, and suet, butter or a vegan alternative. The pastry is up to the baker, but the filling has to be recognisably mincemeat. Pies that don’t pass can be ruled out.

Can I review pies with extra flavours, like chocolate or nuts?

Yes, as long as the filling is still mostly traditional mincemeat.

Can I review mini pies?

Yes. Many brands sell normal and mini versions of the same pie, so tick “This is the mini version” when you add one. Minis are scored separately from the full-size pie.

Can I enter a homemade pie?

Yes. Reviews from the baker’s household or family don’t count, so you’ll be asked to confirm you’re neither. Homemade pies need three reviews like any other.

I made a mistake in my review.

You can delete a review yourself for 30 minutes after posting it, then post it again. After that, ask Lee to fix it.

When are the winners announced?

Reviews close on 23 December and the results go live on the evening of 23 December. They’ll be on the results page.

Are there prizes?

No. It’s for fun, for the community, and for the glory of finding the best mince pie.